Thursday, March 18, 2010

Electronic registry to eliminate home funding frauds



Must ensure free access to citizens, writes R.P.Deshpande


For transparency: More transparency required.

Buyers and financial institutions are often duped by unscrupulous sellers and loan seekers by concealing the mortgage related information of a property. The properties that have been already funded by a bank are submitted afresh for loans by manipulating the documents. Buyers unaware of such frauds end up buying them only to find that they have inherited liability. It is reported that the banks have lost amounts of nearly Rs. 400 crore and the personal loss of the buyers have not yet been precisely calculated.

Such criminal practices may soon come to end and buying properties or seeking home loans would become reactively transparent. The budget recently unveiled by the Union Government has proposed to set up a Central Electronic Registry, data base of all properties mortgaged to banks and HFCs (Home Finance Companies). It will collect, collate the information of mortgages and circulate the same back to all banks and HFCs. When a bank/HFC processes a home loan proposal, it will first verify with the central registry if the title to the property is clear and the property is not already mortgaged to any other Bank/HFC. This way multiple funding on one property can be avoided and also fake documents detected.

This proposal has its own advantages over the registration of mortgages under the Transfer of property of Act of Property Act, 1882.

Normally, a mortgagor (borrower) deposits his or her title deeds with mortgagee (lending institution) as security for the loan availed. This is beneficial for both the borrowers and as well as lenders, since the procedure followed is simple, convenient, less expensive and less/no paper work is involved. A mere deposit of title deeds with an intention to create security is sufficient to affect the equitable mortgage. As it is difficult to establish the intention to create security, many banks/HFCs insist on executing a memorandum evidencing deposit of title deeds. Once the deposit of title deeds is reduced in writing, in many states, it attracts stamp duty varying between 0.25% and 0.5% of loan amount. While this may be convenient, the details of the mortgage will not appear in the EC (Encumbrance Certificate) issued by Sub-Registrar or title search reports.
This information gap has been exploited . It is here that the proposal to set up a central registry proves good. The registry will help Banks and HFCs to have beforehand information on mortgages created, if any, on the property to be funded. The procedure to verify information on mortgages would be simple and economical .
But this is not sufficient.

The objective of setting up the proposed central agency will be incomplete, until an ordinary citizen has access to the central registry to verify that the property he or she intends to buy is not already mortgaged and the property is not being sold to him on fake documents.

(The author is a Director of Institute of Home Finance and can be contacted at deshpanderp2007@gmail.com.)

Source: The Hindu

Monday, March 15, 2010

Get up to Rs 6 lakh home loan, without documents

Posted March 15, 2010
A housing finance company feels that documents
like salary slips are not the only way to judge the
credit-worthiness of a potential borrower

If you want a loan to buy an affordable home, but do
not have enough documents (like salary slips), do not
worry. Micro Housing Finance Corp Ltd (MHFC) is
ready to provide a loan of up to Rs6 lakh for people
who do not posses these documents.

“We do not believe that documents are the only
way to test the trust of a client. I do not think that a
salary slip will actually determine whether he or she
will be able to repay the loan or not,” said Rajnish Dhall,
founder, MHFC.

“A salary slip will only show how much a person earns,
but there are other ways to check the earning and
repayment capacity of a borrower.
You can conduct independent verification
and surveys to know that. For example, if I am lending to
a vegetable vendor, then I observe his business.
I see him every day on the street from 9 in the morning to 8 at night.
You can easily make an estimate of his earning,” added Mr Dhall.


According to the latest National Sample Survey Organisation
(NSSO) report, there are over 80 million poor people living
in India. The slum population is also increasing and as per the
Town and Country Planning Organisation’s (TCPO) estimates
in 2001, over 61.8 million people in India were living in slums.

There is a huge demand for affordable housing supported by
easy finance for this segment. Many banks reject loan
applications of a prospective client if his company
does not have a provident fund facility as the applicant might
be working in a small & medium enterprise.
Besides the urban poor, a person earning Rs 8,000-Rs15,000
per month can approach this
micro-finance company for a home loan.

MHFC is targeting people like vegetable vendors, maids,
taxi-drivers, etc. In fact, its first customer is a food vendor, the
second is a housemaid, and the third a beautician.

“We conduct personal interviews of the customers and carry out surveys to know about the earnings of people from a particular segment. We can easily make out what a taxi-driver or maid earns. If we are lending money to a maid, we call the employer to enquire more on her earnings. We conduct ample number of enquires before lending,” added Mr Dhall.

The company has an equity capital of Rs33 crore. It has already disbursed around Rs2.50 crore to about 100 borrowers. “We have plans to sanction loans worth Rs60 crore by next year,” claimed Mr Dhall.
“We only mortgage the house being financed. To sanction a loan, we do not require a guarantor or any other security,” said Nachiket Shelgikar, co-founder, MHFC.

MHFC charges a prime lending rate (PLR) of 12% to clients and provides a loan of about 80% of the property value. As a security, the company mortgages the property being financed. While other banks require a minimum of two or three types of assurances, this company does not. MHFC claims that it has not yet faced any problems with loan repayments.

“We take two weeks to sanction loans from the date of application. We also charge 1% processing fee before disbursal, and the client has to pay a Rs300 application fee, based on which we process the application and provide a sanction,” said Mr Dhall.

The micro-finance company does not advertise. It ties up
with developers who build affordable housing projects
costing between Rs3 lakh to Rs6 lakh per home in urban areas.

When the builder advertises his project, he also adds that he has tied up with MHFC.
At present, the company has tied up with seven affordable projects like Shubh Griha (Boisar, Maharashtra); Global City (Virar, Maharashtra); Swarajya (Ambivali, Maharashtra) and Om Shantinagar 2 (Ahmedabad, Gujarat).

“We are planning to tie up with 20 more projects
which are in the pipeline. We intend to commence
operations shortly in Bengaluru, Surat and Kolkata.

We are also in discussions with various State governments
for housing initiatives for the economically weaker section
or lower income group,” said Madhusudhan Menon, founder, MHFC.

Tata Housing Development Company (THDCL), signed dual MoUs with the Assam government to create commercial developments

 
Kolkatta:March 15,2010
Leading real estate company, Tata Housing Development 
Company (THDCL), signed dual MoUs with the 
Assam government to create commercial developments
in the state, according to a company press release.

The first MoU was signed between THDCL and The
Department of Industries and Commerce of Assam for
creation of commercial space, including business parks
and IT buildings in the state.

The second MoU was signed with the Guwahati
Metropolitan Development Authority (GMDA)
for developing a township and other infrastructure
projects under the Public Private Partnership (PPP)
model within the state, the release said.

“Assam has witnessed various positive developments in
the past and presents vast opportunities–it is poised for
an economic development,” THDCL’s chief executive
officer and managing director, Brotin Banerjee, said.
Tata Housing Development Company is a fully-owned
subsidiary of Tata Sons.

Currently, Tata Sons holds 97.5 per cent of equity share
capital of the company while the balance is held by other group entities.

Puravankara -prefabricated housing plant

 

Bangalore:March 15,2010

Puravankara Projects Ltd (PPL), which is
looking at tapping the affordable home 
segment in a big way, is planning to set up
a prefab housing factory in Bangalore.

The facility will come up close to the site of its affordable housing project and cost around Rs 40-50 crore.
The real estate firm’s low-cost housing subsidiary Provident Housing has already acquired the technology for prefabricated housing from Singapore-based Subarna International Consultancy Pvt Ltd.

Ashish Puravankara, director of PPL, said his company would soon be setting up these factories at its various affordable housing project locations to expedite project delivery.

“We have got the technology (from Subarna) and will be setting prefab housing factories on a need basis for our future (affordable home) projects,” he said.
 
Puravankara also said the company had not yet zeroed in on foreign a partner for its affordable housing projects. Mexican-based developer Homex is reportedly the leading contender for such a partnership.
“We are in talks with various companies for the tie-up in the affordable homes segment at the moment,” he said.
PPL’s low-cost housing arm is on a lookout for an international homebuilder engaged in the affordable housing segment to speed up its project delivery to 10-12 months through use of technology.

Such a move would also help it widen its reach in low-cost homes to Rs 8-22 lakh from the current Rs 15-22 lakh.
Analysts Suman Memani and Ronald Siyoni of Religare Hichens Harrison in their report on Wednesday said PPL’s proposed alliance with a foreign firm and its collaboration with Subrana for prefab housing will lead to a massive jump in revenues from affordable housing arm.

Memani and Siyoni expect further ramp up in earnings from low-cost housing in FY11.
“We expect Provident to launch 6 million square feet (msf) in Bangalore over the next quarter and a total of 30 msf in 2011 as the benefits of its international partnerships materialise,” they wrote in their report.

In all, the company aims to build around 65,000 affordable homes across 60 msf in the next 5-6 years.
But as the realty firm chases volumes to improve cash flow through its affordable housing strategy, it may see some erosion in its margins.

“While PPL earns a standalone Ebitda margin of 30-35%, Provident is likely to earn lower margins of 22-25%. However, cash flows in affordable housing are likely to pip those in the mid segment due to speedy delivery,” said the Religare analysts.It will speed up delivery, push cash flow but squeeze margins

Ambuja Realty plans to invest Rs.1,065 crore



KOLKATA: 15th March,2010

 

Real estate company Ambuja Realty plans to invest Rs.1,065 crore
over the next three to four years on commercial and residential complexes 
and business parks, the company’s chairman said here Thursday.

“We have plans for three more business parks in Kolkata —
two in Salt Lake Sector V and one in Rajarhat,” company
chairman Harshavardhan Neotia said after inaugurating
first phase of Ecospace business park in New Town.

The three business parks would require an investment of
around Rs.295 crore. Apart from these business parks in the city,
the company would also take up commercial and residential
complex project in Siliguri in Darjeeling district (Rs.250 crore),
Haldia City Centre project (Rs.70 crore) in East Midnapore,
commercial complex project in Patna (Rs.300 crore) and Raipur
commercial complex project (Rs.150 crore), he said.

Most of the investments would be done through internal
accruals, he said. Talking about the first phase of the Ecospace
business park, Neotia said almost 85 percent space of the park is
already occupied by various companies.


Corporate houses at Ecospace include Bajaj Allianz, HDFC Bank,
Voith, Thyssenkrupp, Indus Towers and Bayer CorpScience.
The second phase of Ecospace would be completed in a year, he said.

http://panindiaproperties.blogspot.com/

Before buying any property, seek professional consultation

 

MEERA MURUGESAN

Before buying any property, seek professional consultation,
advises MEERA MURUGESAN

TWO years ago, Anita and Jeff came across an advertisement.
A double-storey terrace house was for sale.
It was in a location they had planned to live in and the
price was within their budget.


They had found their dream home, or so they thought.


Being first-time house buyers, the couple were eager to land the property.


A month after moving in, Jeff and Anita realised they had made a mistake.


The house had been advertised as “move-in condition” but the couple
soon found themselves forking out huge sums for repairs.


“We had endless internal plumbing problems and had to redo
wiring for the entire house. We are paying so much for repairs
because something gets broken all the time,” Anita says.
In their eagerness to secure the property, they failed to
notice the hidden costs that would incur from the purchase.


“The previous owner had painted the place and patched things up
to make it look presentable so we failed to notice just how bad
the condition of the place really was,” says Jeff.


For Farah, a single executive from Petaling Jaya, her dream of
owning a condominium has ended in frustration.


She signed up to purchase a yet-to-be built condominium
from a developer during a home owner’s campaign in 1999.


She liked the location of the condominium, the facilities promised
and the fact that the developer seemed reputable.
She was confident of getting ownership of the property by 2002.

Chang advises buyers to appoint their own lawyers
Chang advises buyers to appoint their own lawyers

Unfortunately, for Farah, the developer went bankrupt in 2001
and till today, there has been no news of the project being revived.


“I paid close to RM10,000 to complete the initial transactions.
I’m still servicing my loan for the property but I don’t have a home,"
says a disgruntled Farah.


Despite frequent meetings with the developer’s representatives
and even lodging a complaint with authorities, Farah and other
affected house buyers are no closer to seeing their dream become a reality.


“The developer has been asking buyers to fork out more money
to revive the project. Yet they can’t give any assurance on when
the project will be completed," Farah says.


The cases above are classic examples of challenges faced by
house buyers in Malaysia and the common mistakes some
first-time purchasers make, says Chang Kim Loong, honorary
secretary-general of the National House Buyers Association (HBA).


Chang says for many people, the purchase of a house or
apartment is the most important financial decision of their lives.
Unfortunately, one wrong move can result in a lifetime of problems.


As in Anita and Jeff’s case, many people pay for a house
and discover defects later which cost them thousands to repair.


Chang explains that this would not have happened if the
couple had hired a professional, such as an independent
building inspector or quality consultant to report on the
condition of the house and check for permitted renovations
against shoddy renovations before they made the purchase.


In fact, the report would have given them additional
room for negotiation with the seller.


In America and Canada, home inspections are standard
practice in the purchasing process.


Home inspectors conduct inspections of newly-built or
previously owned homes.


Another mistake that many house buyers make is failing
to appoint their own lawyer before starting any transaction
with the present owner of the property.


“The first rule of conveyancing is that the buyer must engage
his own lawyer and consult a lawyer right from the start, and
not after you have paid the deposit,” Chang says. In most cases,
a lawyer would be able to complete the transaction.


However, lawyers with a focused real estate practice may
prove a better tool if the buyer is unsure of what to do or
if there are complications in the purchase agreement or mortgage.


“While you may think you cannot afford the services of your
own lawyer, consider whether you can afford not to,” cautions Chang.


A lawyer ensures that his client’s rights and interests are
protected and that his client is aware of the rights, risk and
responsibilities before signing an agreement.


They also ensure that negotiations lead to a fair agreement
binding each party to the contract with no uncertainties.

Chang says a lawyer should not be representing both
parties in the sale. If, for example, the buyer decides to
use the seller’s lawyer, when disputes happen, that lawyer
is unlikely to represent him against his client.


When purchasing a home from a developer, many
house buyers are also easily taken in by phrases such as
“free legal fees” in the developer’s brochure.


Chang says in these type of transactions, the developer
recommends a lawyer to the buyer to attend to the sale
contract and the developer pays the lawyer’s fees.

The buyer is given the impression that if he uses this
recommended lawyer, he gets things done free.


In reality, the recommended lawyer has a conflict of interest.
He or she is on the developer’s panel and would be receiving
work from current or future projects from the developer.


“How can such a lawyer act impartially for the buyer if problems
arise later such as delay in delivery of vacant possession or shoddy
workmanship? That’s why it’s always advisable for each party to
appoint its own lawyer,” says Chang.


When purchasing from a developer, many people also make
the mistake of assuming that a developer’s property is a
guaranteed investment or that the property will be completed
and delivered with vacant possession and a certificate of
completion and compliance. In fact, Chang says, consumers
must first understand the difference between a “Sell-Then-Build” (STB)
or “Build-Then-Sell” (BTS) variant property. Understanding the difference
could save a lot of heartache and financial loss.


STB means buyers will finance the building of the property in
progressive stages. It’s like buying a car and paying for it progressively.


“For example, when the car doors are fixed, 10 per cent is paid,
when the tyres are fixed, another 10 per cent is paid, when the
engine is installed, 15 per cent is paid and so on,” Chang says.


On the other hand, a BTS property means the developer
substantially finances the building of the property. It means buyers
will pay only after the whole “car” is completed and delivered in
good working order, with the authorities’ approval. Chang says
if the STB property is not completed, buyers are stuck in the sale
contract with huge amounts of money already paid to the developer.


But if the BTS property is not completed, buyers can opt to
break away from the contract with relatively smaller losses.


The HBA has always advocated the BTS concept as it
has been tried and tested successfully in neighbouring
countries and prevents buyers from being burdened with
problems such as shoddy workmanship or abandoned projects.


“It is a more straightforward and secure deal for buyers,” says
Chang. Auction properties also come across as very attractive
to many prospective buyers because of the lower pricing but
consumers may not realise the hidden dangers involved.


As the auction properties are sold on an “as is where is” basis,
this means new buyers assume responsibilities for
whatever encumbrances or outstanding debts on the property.


Chang says the property may also have many problems such
as broken water pipes or old electrical wiring that buyers
usually discover only after taking possession.


Buyers must bear in mind that there is little chance
of any physical inspection of the property prior to
purchase and delivery of vacant possession is also not
guaranteed.
http://panindiaproperties.blogspot.com/

What this budget means for real estate




RAMESH NAIR


The Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee presented 
the 2010 Budget last Friday. Although at the macro 
level it is a growth oriented budget and growth in 
the economy always leads to growth in the real 
estate sector, the reaction from the real estate 
sector has been mixed.

The real estate industry is an extremely important sector which
contributes significantly to the country's GDP, employing almost
20 million people and supporting more than 250 affiliate industries.
The overall reaction has been positive. The best part of the
budget has been that the income tax slabs have been raised
which will increase disposable income in the hands of the middle
class. Given below are the upside and the downside of the budget.


Positives
The overall allocation for infrastructure has increased to Rs.1.73 lakh crore with allocation for roads increasing to Rs. 20,000 crore. Better road infrastructure results in easier accessibility and creation of more land worth developing leading to lower cost of real estate.

The revision in personal income tax rates will put more money in the pockets of the middle class, increasing the buying power and affordability to buy homes.

Interest subvention of 1% for 10 lakhs of the loan amount will be given to the customers provided the cost of the property doesn't exceed Rs. 20 lakhs. The budgetary allocation for the same is earmarked at Rs. 700 crores.

The increase in allocation for slum redevelopment under the Rajiv Awaz Yojana to Rs 1,270 crore will ensure that key areas in city centres will begin to yield quality real estate supply. The allocations have also increased for rural housing under the Indira Awaz Yajana and 66,000 crore has been allocated for rural infrastructure development. Tax holiday on profits under Section 80 IB has been extended up to March 2013 with developers getting an extension of a year for completion of projects.

The warehousing sector will benefit with the ongoing scheme for private sector participation for Food Corporation of India to hire warehouses from private players for a guaranteed period of 7 years and with external commercial borrowings to be available for development of cold storages.

Negatives
· Service tax will be now applicable on sale of residential units during the construction period. This will increase total purchase price to the end consumer by around 3.3%.

· Service tax will also be applicable on rental income from commercial pro
perty including lease of office and land and on additional amenities such as floor rise and preferential location. This has been brought in with retrospective effect from June 1, 2007.

The Budget did not mention relaxing FDI into the real estate sector or REITs and REMFs.
There was also lack of affirmative action on increasing tax exemptions on housing loans, principal repayment and interest under section 80C and 24B respectively. This would have encouraged more home buyers to invest in real estate for tax saving purposes.

More clarity The developers were expecting the re-introduction of section 80 IB (10) tax benefit scheme. This was not considered. If this was reintroduced, the developers would have shared part of their profits with buyers and also increase the supply of smaller homes making homes more affordable.

The software companies, developers and owners of IT space were expecting more clarity in terms of the extension of tax exemption under the Software Technologies Park of India (STPI) scheme. This has not been addressed. This is expected to increase demand for space in IT SEZ's and further add to the problems of STPI developments.

The increase in excise duty on cement will push up construction costs increasing the burden on the home buyer.

Also many of the pre-budget expectations from the developer community such as industry status for the real state sector, rationalising stamp duty across all states, extending 80 ID tax holiday for hotels, reduction of works contract tax and VAT, infrastructure status for townships, single window clearance system for integrated townships, extension of the tax benefits under 80 IA of the industrial parks scheme and allowing of external commercial borrowing in the real estate sector were not addressed. Many of these would have also indirectly helped the consumer.



Ramesh Nair
is a Managing Director
with Jones Lang LaSalle Meghrajand

Real Estates: Booming Industry in India


Everyone has the dream to have a house. 
And it is such a scenario where so many people now
have started living in nuclear families.

Break-ups in joint families during last few decades promote
the people to buy home and apartments for their own.
In the last few decades, the income of middle class people
is rising. Apart from the income factor, low interest rate on
bank housing loan and young generation's modern thought
for house ownership are some basic reasons for development
in the real estate industry.

Real estate is such an industry which is blooming very vastly
during the last few decades. The growth of this industry has
moved to 35 per cent, which is estimated about US $ 15 billion
and in future decades it is expected to grow at 30 per cent annually.

It shows that people will be influenced towards this sector.
After the year 1995, large number of business groups, IT
companies and BPOs have moved to Indian market for
establishing their offices, hotels, factories, workshop.

This has given a huge boost to the real estate market.
In India this industry is engaged in residential and commercial
constructions. Commercial property is especially designed for
business, industrial and institutional activity for generating revenue
and profits. And residential property is for residents only. Delhi and
NCR, Mumbai, Kolkata and Chennai are such metro cities where
it has worked beautifully. Prices of property, houses,
apartments, offices are moving higher, because of progress in the realty sector.

Infrastructural development of any country depends on its realty
sector development. For introducing foreign companies, hospitals,
schools, townships, offices the country needs development in the realty sector.

India's economy is a developing one. And Reality sector forms 5-6 per
cent of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Large scale investment,
rapid urbanization and Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) are contributing
to the growth of real estate sector in India. Government also
promotes the international business groups to invest in this industry.

It is such an industry where so many of job opportunity exist and
it promotes several different industries like glass, iron, cement, paint, steel etc.

After the introduction of of international business groups in realty
sector market prices of property are scaling newer and newer heights.

They offer as much cost as a property owner demands.
When the prices of property in metro cities are very high they
are moving to smaller towns.

Every middle class family has the dream about their own home.
Housing Loan is provided by the banks and various financing companies.

They issue home loans for purchasing of house, building and apartment,
against some securities and thes elife insurance policy  securities are
assignments, guarantee from one person to another, share deposits.
The maximum amount of loan for purchasing and constructions in
rural areas is Rs. 25 lack and for semi-urban, urban and metros
is Rs. 100 lacks. Bank and financial institution also check borrower's
financial status. After that, loan provided by them covers
about 80-85 percent of the total cost of home.

Banks like State of India, Punjab National Bank, ICICI, HDFC bank
etc., are such banks which provide Housing Loan to those people
who want loan for purchasing a home. Interest rate of these
banks are very user friendly.

Author: jolly

Central registry to verify that the property mortgage

 



Buyers and financial institutions are often duped 
by unscrupulous sellers and loan seekers by
concealing the mortgage related information of a property.

The properties that have been already funded by a bank 
are submitted afresh for loans by manipulating the documents. 

Buyers unaware of such frauds end up buying them only to find
that they have inherited liability. It is reported that the banks have
lost amounts of nearly Rs. 400 crore and the personal loss 
of the buyers have not yet been precisely calculated.





Such criminal practices may soon come to end and buying 
properties or seeking home loans would become reactively transparent.

The budget recently unveiled by the Union Government has proposed to
set up a Central Electronic Registry, data base of all properties
mortgaged to banks and HFCs (Home Finance Companies).
It will collect, collate the information of mortgages and circulate 
the same back to all banks and HFCs. When a bank/HFC processes
a home loan proposal, it will first verify with the central registry if the
title to the property is clear and the property is not already
mortgaged to any other Bank/HFC. 

This way multiple funding on one property can be
avoided and also fake documents detected.

This proposal has its own advantages over the 
registration of mortgages under the Transfer of 
property of Act of Property Act, 1882.


Normally, a mortgagor (borrower) deposits his or
her title deeds with mortgagee (lending institution)
as security for the loan availed. This is beneficial for 
both the borrowers and as well as lenders, since the
procedure followed is simple, convenient, less expensive
and less/no paper work is involved. A mere deposit of title 
deeds with an intention to create security is sufficient to 
affect the equitable mortgage.



As it is difficult to establish the intention to 
create security, many banks/HFCs insist on executing
a memorandum evidencing deposit of title deeds.

Once the deposit of title deeds is reduced in writing,
in many states, it attracts stamp duty varying 
between 0.25% and 0.5% of loan amount. 

While this may be convenient, the details of the
mortgage will not appear in the EC (Encumbrance Certificate) 
issued by Sub-Registrar or title search reports.


This information gap has been exploited . It is here that
the proposal to set up a central registry proves good. 
The registry will help Banks and HFCs to have beforehand 
information on mortgages created, if any, on the property
to be funded. The procedure to verify information on 
mortgages would be simple and economical .
But this is not sufficient.



The objective of setting up the proposed central agency
will be incomplete, until an ordinary citizen has access
to the central registry to verify that the property he or she
intends to buy is not already mortgaged and the property
is not being sold to him on fake documents.

Ready mixed concrete is manufacturing activity and additional depreciation is allowable

 

Mixing of ready mixed concrete is manufacturing activity
and additional depreciation is allowable on machinery used for mixing

Mar 14, 2010


CASE LAW DETAILS

Decided by:, ITAT, BENCH `F’. NEW DELHI,  
In The case of: YFC Projects Pvt. Ltd. v. DCIT, 
Appeal No.:, ITA No. 4672/Del/2007, 
Decided on: January 15, 2010

RELEVANT PARAGRAPH


6. We have considered the rival contentions and gone through the records carefully. Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of India Cine Agencies (supra) has considered various judgments of Hon’ble High Court as well of Hon’ble Supreme Court, while. construing the meaning of expression, manufacture and production.

Hon’ble Court has also considered the judgment in the case of N.C. Budhjraja & Co. (supra) has been relied upon by the Assessing Officer. The Hon’ble Court has considered the dictionary meaning of expression “manufacture” as well as how this term has been construed and expounded by the courts in various judgments. The authoritative observations of the Hon’ble Court are worth to note for understanding the meaning of word “manufacture” :

“2., As noted above, the core issue is whether the activity undertaken was manufacture or production.

3. In Black’s Law Dictionary (5th edition), the word , “the “manufacture” has been defined as, “the-process or operation of 1 makings goods or any material produced by hand, by machinery or by other agency; by the hand, by machinery, or by art. Theproduction of articles for use from raw or prepared materials by giving such materials new forms, qualities, properties or combinations, whether by hand labour or I machine”.

Thus, by a process ofmanufacture something is I produced and brought into existence which is different from that, out of which it is made in the sense that the thing produced r from that, out of which it is made in the sense that the thing | produced is by itself a commercial commodity capable of being sold or supplied. The material from which the thing or product is manufactured may necessarily lose its identity or may become transformed into the basic or essential properties £see JI “Dy. Commissioner of Sales-tax (Law), Board of Revenue (Taxes) Coco Fibres (1992) Supp (1) SCC 290:)

4. Manufacture implies a change but every change is not manufacture, yet every change of an article is the result of treatment, labour and manipulation. Naturally, manufacture is 1 the end result of one or more process through which the original commodities are made to pass. The nature and extent of processing may vary from one case to another. There may be several stages of processing, a different kind of processing at each stage. With each process suffered, the original commodity experiences a change.

Whenever a commodity undergoes a . change as a result of some operation performed o it or ^regard . to it, such operation would amount the processing of the commodity. But it is only when the change or a series of changes takes the commodity to the point-where commercially it can no longer be regarded as the original commodity but instead is recognized as a new and distinct article that amanufacture can be said to take place. Process in manufacture or in relation to manufacture implies not only the production but also various stages through which the raw material is subjected to change by different operations.
 
It is the cumulative effect of the various processes to which the raw material is subjected that the manufactured product emerges. Therefore, each step towards suchproduction would be a process in relation to the manufacture. Where any particular process is so integrally connected with the ultimate production of goods that but for that process processing of goods would be impossible or commercially inexpedient, that process is one in relation to themanufacture. Collector of Central Excise. v. Rajasthan State Chemical Works 1991 4 SCC 473.

5. “Manufacture” is a transformation of an article, which is commercially different from the one, which is converted. The essence of manufacture is the change of one object to another for the purpose of making it marketable. The essential point thus is that in manufacture something is brought into existence, which is different from that which originally existed in the sense that the thing produced is by itself a commercially different commodity whereas inthe case of processing it is not necessary to produce a commercially different article. (83% Saraswati Sugar Mills v. Haryana State Board |1992J 1 SCC 418

6. The prevalent and generally accepted test to ascertain that there is “manufacture” is whether the change or the series of change brought about by the application of processes take the commodity to the point where, commercially, it can no longer be regarded as the original commodity but is, instead, recognized as a distinct and new article that has emerged as a result of the process. There might be borderline cases where either conclusion with equal justification can be reached. Insistence on any sharp or intrinsic distinction between “processing andmanufacture ” , results in an oversimplification^ of both and tends to blur their interdependence. Ujagar Prints v. Union of India 1989 3 SCC 488

7, To put it differently, the test to determine whether a particular activity amounts to “manufacture” or not is :

Do new and different goods emerge having distinctive name, use and character. The moment there is transformation into a new commodity commercially known as a distinct and separate commodity having its own character, use and name, whether it be the result of one process or several processes “manufacture’ ‘ _ takes place and liability to duty is attracted Etymologically the word “manufacture” properly construed would doubtless cover I the transformation. It is the transformation of a matter into something else and that something else is a question of degree whether that something else is a different commercial commodity having its distinct character, use and name and I commercially known as such from that point of view, is a question depending upon the facts and circumstances ofthe case. Empire Industries Ltd. v. Union of India 1985 3 SCC 314)”

7. In the light of above judgment, if we examine the activity of the assessee then it would reveal that preparation of RMC is not as simple as construed by the learned QT(Appeals). The assessee has been carrying out this activity in an organized manner with the help of heavy machinery and computer. Its activity is not as simply as mixing of sand, cement etc. by a labourer on the right side.

Though in the common parlance, sometime it does not sound logic to say that mixing of R.M.C. is amanufacturing activity but if we look into this activity carried out by the assessee from the point of an expert who has laid down BIS standard placed on the paper book then it would indicate that it is a complicated affairs. The mixing of four products in prescribed ratio would result a different identifiable product which cannot be reconverted to its original shape.

Hon’bleSupreme Court in the case of India Cine Agencies (supra) has considered cutting of a jumbo films rolls into small piece of films a manufacturing activity. If we analysis the facts of assessee’s case, as per the ratios of Hon’ble Supreme Court ’s decision then its case is on a better footings. Therefore, we are of the opinion that Learned Revenue Authority have erred in holding that assessee is not carrying out anymanufacturing activity.

We allow the first issue raised by the assessee
and pleaded in ground Nos. 3 to 5. We direct the
Assessing Officer to allow additional depreciation
onmachinery used for the production of ready mixed concrete.